Contact Us

Where CNN Went Wrong in Promoting Time-lapse Photography as a Revolutionary New Technology to Improve IVF Outcomes

CHR investigators examine the efficacy of embryoscopy, a closed embryo incubation system, and urge patients to be wary of unfounded marketing claims of improved IVF pregnancy rates, especially in light of its high cost and lack of clinical evidence.

There is no evidence so far that embryoscopy improves IVF outcomes. Patients should not be pushed to carry the financial burden of an unproven technology, when cost of IVF is already very high.

    NEW YORK, NY, July 07, 2014 /24-7PressRelease/ -- An automated embryo incubation system with time-lapse photography, collectively known as "embryoscopy," a costly new laboratory technology of unproven efficacy, is widely marketed by manufacturers and fertility clinics as a tool to improve in vitro fertilization (IVF) pregnancy chances, warn investigators at the Center for Human Reproduction (CHR), a leading fertility center in New York City.

Embryoscopy allows embryos to develop in a closed, automated incubation environment, with constant observation by computerized time-lapse photography. Proponents of this technique argue that it offers two distinct advantages: (1) It removes manual interventions by embryologists once egg and sperm have been placed into the closed system; and (2) serial observations of the fertilization process and subsequently developing embryos allow for improved embryo selection. Combined, both advantages should lead to better IVF pregnancy rates.

In the latest piece in CHR's OPINIONs commentary series, CHR examines the claims made by proponents of embryoscopy, including some IVF centers, which, like manufacturers of these instruments, use adoption of embryoscopy at their centers as marketing tools to attract patients. The OPINION piece concludes that, at least so far, claims of improvements in IVF outcomes are scientifically unfounded, as no study published so far in the world was able to demonstrate IVF outcome advantages from the use of embryoscopy systems.

Some studies have demonstrated significant differences in the speed of embryo development in these culture systems. However, not even a single study so far has been able to demonstrate differences in final outcomes from clinical decisions made based on these observations. It is also still unknown whether observed differences are typical for all embryos or only reflect culture conditions created by these instruments.

Despite the lack of evidence of efficacy, these systems are aggressively marketed to IVF centers as well as to the public, at unit prices approaching, and sometimes exceeding, $100,000. Even CNN recently fell victim to these marketing efforts, when Sanjay Gupta, MD, the network's Chief Medical Correspondent, anchored a special half-hour program, declaring embryoscopy to be a "revolutionary product" in IVF.

Summarizing CHR's opinion, Norbert Gleicher, MD, CHR's Medical Director and Chief Scientist, notes: "Embryoscopy is a very interesting research tool with considerable potential. It, indeed, at some point in the future may detect morphological markers of superior embryo quality. However, at the current time, it does not improve IVF outcomes and, in contrast to CNN's message, cannot be considered as 'revolutionary' or even beneficial in clinical IVF."

The OPINION piece further explains that CHR considers embryoscopy a research instrument, which should be only used in properly conducted clinical trials, and should not be imposed on the public as part of a routine IVF process, further increasing the costs of IVF that is for many patients already prohibitively expensive.

The full commentary can be found along with the complete series of OPINIONs on CHR's website at www.centerforhumanreprod.com/chr_opinions.html.

The Center for Human Reproduction (CHR), located in New York City, is one of the world's leading clinical and research centers in reproductive medicine and infertility. Always vocal on issues impacting fertility patients, CHR has, based on the center's research and peer reviewed publications, become one of the most prominent opinion leaders in the field. Dr. Gleicher is available for further comments.


# # #



Comment on this story...

Share This Story


Email this Story

Contact Information


Communications Manager
Center for Human Reproduction

New York, NY
USA
Voice: 212-994-4400
E-Mail: Email Us Here
Website: Visit Our Website

Like This Story?


I like it! 0

Disclaimer


If you have any questions regarding information in this press release, please contact the person listed in the contact module of this page. Please do not attempt to contact 24-7 Press Release Newswire. We are unable to assist you with any information regarding this release. 24-7 Press Release Newswire disclaims any content contained in this press release. Please see our complete Terms of Service disclaimer for more information.